Share More sharing options. out of these bands, i listened to a lot of led zep, doors, and pink floyd in high school. Joined: Nov 2, 2012 Messages: 7,172 August 27, 2020. . The Stones own this poll. Threads 10 Messages 12. The Rolling Stones vs. Queen vs. Since their nine albums were recorded between 1968 and 1979, Led Zeppelin has been one of the most popular bands of all time, having sold more than 300. Lyrics For Led Zeppelin Tracks. They were more innovative, artistic, and influential than any other band in history. The soundtrack to the film, produced by Jimmy Page, was originally released in 1976. People like their music and their unique style, but many other bands have great sound too. Led Zeppelin IV or Zoso, released in 1971, is Led Zeppelin's best-selling album ever and the ninth best-selling album of all time. Vote, comment, and suggest another video idea!Subscribe for. i agree with all the things you just said but what i was saying is that if roger waters was the bassist for Zepp instead of Floyd, he would not have been able to direct and control the band (Zepp) as much as he did with Floyd, becasue i almost guarantee that Page and Plant would have bnot put up with his sh*t..all the floyd members kind alet Waters take the lead role and direct the band in a . . SolidSnake15. They were so proud of the lyrics that they . This is because I like darker music better, and Pink Floyd pulled it off nicely. Joined Jun 16, 2015 The Dark Side of The Moon, released in 1973, remained on the Billboard chart for a record-setting 741 weeks from 1973 -1988. . . The Stones own this poll. Published. Keith Moon died sleeping, September 7th, 1978, a victim of an accidental overdose due to medication for his alcohol addiction. And now I'm bracing for the disdain from the hard core Pink Floyd fans: "It isn't even really Pink Floyd without Roger Waters. Led Zeppelin shouldn't be compared to bands like Lynyrd Skynyrd. . Now you might look at your post of "The Who vs Led Zeppelin" and be embarrassed, there you are saying which bands you prefer, and there isn't actual facts there proving your . If you mean live shows, It would be. Es conocido por sus canciones de contenido filosfico, la experimentacin snica, las innovadoras portadas de sus discos y sus elaborados . Just too many reasons to list. Led Zeppelin are a popular British band best known for their iconic "Stairway to Heaven" as well as for co-creating the music genre of heavy metal. Led Zeppelin's soundtrack to their concert film The Song Remains The Same has been remastered and will be reissued across multiple formats in September. From: USA, NV. Discussion in 'Mayberry Lounge' started by theycallitMurda, Jun 30, 2014. . Led Zeppelin - TSRTS vs. Followers 0. 2=Pink Floyd. Gaga isn't so bad, if you consider the background of the music and times she lives in. Katy Perry would be a far better example of a sugar pop band that surely will be gone tomorrow. Joined Sep 16, 2009 Posts 2,586 . Frank Zappa,Pink Floyd,Yes,Genesis,Rush,King Crimson,Jethro Tull,E.L.P,Rick Wakeman -They have one similarity- I Love Them all ! This time the inspiration was based on Bukka White's Delta blues song "Shake 'Em On Down" as an ode to Zeppelin friend and folk singer Roy Harper. The album is certified 23x platinum the U.S. and is estimated to have . Pink Floyd for the most part sounded like the albums. Led Zeppelin VS Pink Floyd in a high school Battle of the Bands both playing only Beatles covers. So i have to say Led zeppelin is the best band ever .. period. 1,250. lawl. The group consisted of guitarist Jim. to Pink Floyd's advantage, and could go out without being harassed. Led Zeppelin - The Song Remains the Same -or- Pink Floyd - Live at Pompeii It's a big dip until we get to #2, AC/DC and Pink Floyd are tied with 75 million sold. I'm a HUGE Floyd fan and I can still say Zeppelin wins all day long and for every reason. . Highway Star, Smoke on the Water, Child in Time, Strange Kind of Woman, Lazy. Led Zeppelin vs Toto Bad Company vs Journey. Led Zeppelin United Kingdom: Pink Floyd and Led Zeppelin are both excellent, but Pink Floyd is better at what Pink Floyd does. Reply. Led Zeppelin . The band's performances in July 1973, at New York's Madison Square Garden, were recorded for the concert film, The Song Remains The Same. Pink Floyd 2. This #AlbumFight is no different. Led Zeppelin - Stairway to Heaven, of course. Rules are simple: Both bands get one shot, they play a Beatles cover of their choosing and the audience decides. $359.00 (10% off) The Rock Bands & Music Discussion Forum . Zeppelin have the better guitar riffs. Threads 10 Messages 12. mzik listelerini sa sol etmi, ktlelere yn vermi drt mzik grubunun karlatrlmas drm. In December of 2007 Led Zeppelin performed their first full concert since Bonham died in 1980 at London's 02 Arena in honor of the late Ahmet Ertegun. Just too many reasons to list. I'd say led zeplin had better music and Pink Floyd had better production. I have all of their albums, I-IV, Houses of the Holy, Physical Graffiti, In Through the Out Door. Which song is better. Below, we rank all Led Zeppelin albums from worst to best. Hawkwind . 60% (138) Roger Waters, David Gilmour; 39% (90) Robert Plant, Jimmy Page; 228 voters have answered this question. At 7/17/06 04:51 PM, -poxpower- wrote: At 7/17/06 04:48 PM, Noob-Antichrist wrote: Pink Floyd is awesome, quiet you *slap*. Yeah, Pink Floyd is better than Led Zeppelin in my opinion. on 4/16/2011. Man, any random show from the Animals tour kicks its butt". Pink Floyd, Led Zeppelin, Deep purple, Hawkwind, Black Sabbath. Madrigallery. There is NO COMPARISON between Led Zeppelin and Pink Floyd. Led Zeppelin lead the pack by a huge margin. Often the charges of plagiarism leveled against Led Zeppelin involve Robert Plant's lyrics, but that is not the case with "Stairway to Heaven". Led Zeppelin ha sido una de las ms influyentes formaciones dentro del desarrollo del hard rock, sentando a su vez las bases de lo que despus sera conocido como heavy . Who has had a better Solo Careers? That could be good or bad. Very much in the spirit of the 2009 Beatles remasters campaign, EMI has extended the same loving care to their second most important British act - Pink Floyd - with a full-on remastering and repackaging campaign called Why Pink Floyd?, featuring their entire studio output, 14 albums in all.Unlike the Beatles, various titles in the Floyd canon have been revisited before. Which Is Better? 60% (138) Roger Waters, David Gilmour; 39% (90) Robert Plant, Jimmy Page; 228 voters have answered this question. Queen was the better live band, But Led Zeppelin had the better discography (although 70's and 90's Queen was on par with much of LZ's output). On facebook, Floyd has almost twice the number of "likes" that Zeppelin has. Answer (1 of 18): It depends I suppose on what you mean by better If you mean studio musicianship, recording artists, it would have to be 1=Pink Floyd. Reply to this topic; Start new topic; Led Zeppelin - TSRTS vs. Led Zeppelin t-shirt, vintage rare tie dye tee, Black Sabbath Deep Purple Robert Plant Jimmy Page Pink Floyd, all over print 1990. $359.00 (10% off) Lz vs Pink FLoyd Lz vs Queen so i think Lz is always a constant in the world.. Nah, that title belongs to Pink Floyd. Log in; Register . Pink Floyd. Joined: May 1, 2007 Messages: 14,660 Pink Floyd beats Zeppelin also in creativity and feeling. 0. 1. Pink Floyd for sure Pink Floyd has a darker sound and a more dramatic approach than Zeppelin, who have a "party time" approach. Nov 16, 2007 #22 I . Led Zeppelin vs. 375. Madrigallery. I like to party, so I like my rock icons to party too. Led Zeppelin - Wish You Were Here Black DogDOWNLOAD LINK :http://www.mediafire.com/?e0o3w06mvrht3cdhttp://soundcloud.com/antisa/showstopperht. the only one i still put on is zeppelin. 20.09.2008. u 17:24 - PINK FLOYD vs LED ZEPPELIN #74 Bez puno razmiljanja - Pink Floyd. Then again, if you look at some of the disasters Pink Floyd had. Posted on Apr 23rd, 2020, 8:53 AM, , User . MadonnaGirl Elita. Send; Tweet; Pink Floyd (Dark Side, The Wall, Wish You Were Here) 39% (92) Led Zeppelin (Led Zeppelin II, III, & IV) 234 voters have answered this question. A caveat: due to the murky, dubious and variable accounting and reporting practices of the record companies, the RIAA and Billboard, etc., Pink FLoyd - Live at Pompeii. all great songs from a great band. But my number three pick goes to Pink Floyd's Pulse. Pink Floyd- Richard Right (keys), Roger Waters (bass/vocals) , Nick Mason (drums), and David Gilmour (guitar/vocals) . Led Zeppelin steps into the ring with their 3rd album III.Pink Floyd ducks between the ropes with their Magnum Opus, Dark Side of the Moon. Pink Floyd, Metallica, and Judas Priest, are all more diverse, and so is Led Zeppelin. They are not the best rock n roll band of all time, but they are one of the better ones that many people will remember for a long time and will think about even years after their time. Answer (1 of 86): So , this is one of the toughest questions I have ever answered, but I'm gonna make a decision. Re: Battle of the Bands: Pink Floyd vs Led Zeppelin #4 by j.mills Apr 02, 2010 11:38 pm I don't know much Led Zep, but it seems to me that if they didn't exist the world would have missed a great rock band. ThinkGreen Der bermensch. my vote is a given. Pink Floyd. vs. Pink Floyd fue un grupo de rock britnico que cosech gran popularidad gracias a su msica psicodlica, la cual, con el paso del tiempo, fue evolucionando hacia el rock progresivo y el rock sinfnico. 3= Led zeppelin Instrument Musicianship 1= Led Zeppelin. Dark Side of the Moon was the first Pink Floyd album to feature Roger Waters as its sole lyricist. But speaking as a Boomer - and, if only by my own claim, a very knowledgeable one because of my own background as a professional rock musician - I believe that Xers over rate Pink Floyd's greatness - and under rate Led Zeppelin's. I saw Zep twice - and both times they kicked ass and took names. The Beatles 4. Additionally, on streaming platforms, their albums are more popular than Zeppelin's. Pink Floyd has one album in the top 3, two in the top 10, and three in the top 20. Led Zeppelin actually had potential, whereas Pink Floyd really couldn't change much in my view. By CHGOLZFAN, December 7, 2007 in Zep Polls. Upvote for Pink Floyd, Downvote for Led Zeppelin! The Rolling Stones vs. Queen vs. Pink Floyd's songwriting isn't more creative or complex than Led Zeppelin, it's actually more simplistic. Also, these are not just bands, but the energy and sound of an Era, alongside the Stones, The Doors, etc. Another blues arrangement. Zeppelin had a better rhythm section (Roger Taylor lost alot of his flair in the 80's, Deacon was a great songwriter and bassist but can't make up for Taylor's shortcomings). OK Smoke on the Water is OK, but a bit dull. Forum To Discuss Pink Floyd. Aug 28, 2017 #56 BikerDude Dude. lutsik. Let's talk rock! Report Post. Floyd were only progressive in style, but Zep were progressive in substance. Pink Floyd Vs. the only one i still put on is zeppelin. (bkz: hayvan gibi mzik yapyorsunuz yahu) (bkz: jimmy page vs david gilmour vs freddie mercury vs john lennon) hatta yle bir anket . Led Zep looked like rock stars, Pink Floyd looked like the audience, which was prob. The Drummer's Curse. Your desert island suitcase has room for only one of these dvd's. No, no, and no. They spent . But I do prefer LZ, so I might just be biased. (Fun fact: Harper provides lead vocals on Pink Floyd's "Have a Cigar.") It's a weird closing song for 'Led Zeppelin III' but nonetheless enjoyable. Pink FLoyd - Live at Pompeii 158 members have voted. Ever since they topped the charts and appeared on Top of the Pops in the early 70's the press has been behind Zeppelin, and quite right too. 2 yr. ago. The 1970's was the best decade for rock music. ObsoleteSoul, Jun 30, 2014 #7. I love them all (but Pink Floyd are best).. the pretentious Roger Waters crap during the later years, etc., Led Zeppelin had, ratio-wise, a better career. Led Zeppelin - Dazed and ConfusedLive Supershow 1969 Metalrocker77- Robert Plant, voz, armnica y pandereta.- Jimmy Page, guitarra elctrica y acstica.- kela: tm | bugn. Actually Pink Floyd plays with about 20 other people that aren't in the band Pink Floyd ( session musicians) on stage..so ..take that for what it's worth. Led Zeppelin had both aspects going on.in fact I was surprised to find that (according to at least one article I'd read) Zeppelin album sales topped the Floyd's in the U.S. during the period. 1 While Led Zeppelin left a strong impact on music,The Beatles left an impact that transcends music. (297) $323.10. The Beatles were the big bang of rock and roll. Led Zepplin 3. Pink Floyd vs REO Speedwagon Heart vs BTO Moody Blues vs Boston Rolling Stones vs Steve Miller . It seems like more people now like DSOTM for its imagery, not for its music, whereas modern fans of LZ are generally more music-centric. By. But speaking as a Boomer - and, if only by my own claim, a very knowledgeable one because of my own background as a professional rock musician - I believe that Xers over rate Pink Floyd's greatness - and under rate Led Zeppelin's. I saw Zep twice - and both times they kicked ass and took names. Pink Floyd, Led Zeppelin, Deep purple, Hawkwind, Black Sabbath. PINK FLOYD I had to take a couple weeks off from everything due to personal reasons, but now that everything has been taken care of, the Temporary Rough Venom Battle of the Classic Bands Tournament moves forward in 2013 to the quarter finals. Led Zeppelin t-shirt, vintage rare tie dye tee, Black Sabbath Deep Purple Robert Plant Jimmy Page Pink Floyd, all over print 1990. Period. Results | Messages. (EB) The difference between Zeppelin and The Who is basically how they managed the death of their drummers. Pink Floyd is along with The Beatles and Led Zeppelin the most overrated rock band of all time. So. 1. 8. led zeppelin vs pink floyd vs queen vs the beatles. Notice the professionalism oozing out of our updated bracket to announce this week's . No they are not. Led Zeppelin just went up on stage the 4 . Stones man myself. Nov 16, 2007 #21 With all due respect this is a Zep VS Skynyrd thread . Poruka 23.620. Nevertheless, these are the bands making music right now who've hijacked the legendary Led Zeppelin sound while simultaneously making it their own. Sep 19, 2016 #53 Mr. The general public seems to agree. It may just be me, but it seems like Pink Floyd is much more marketed now than Led Zeppelin is, almost to where PF has an artificial fanbase. Joined: 12-April 08. Pink Floyd remains THE favorite band and Deep Purple is one of my favorite bands lol. Idk lol. In Through the Out Door (1979) For our interests here, we're considering In Through the Out Door the last proper Led Zeppelin album . Pink Floyd. / 81 . Pink Floyd. Posted November 22, 2008. dlvette. Page vs. Gilmour: PAGE's classic riffs and awesome solos CANNOT BE TOUCHED BY Gilmour, the . Personally I think Pink Floyd > Zeppelin. Response to Led Zeppelin vs Pink Floyd Jul 17, 2006. Pink Floyd didn't stop . Nirvana vs Green Day. 2=The Beatles. Album: Presence [1976] Mar 11, 2022; changeling; Hawkwind. They only really had one BAD album. 1. Led Zeppelin VS Queen VS Dire Straits VS Pink Floyd (Guitar Battle)This is a different Guitar Battle (Four epic bands, Four Guitar Gods, only one Guitar RIFF. Pink Floyd must have being doing something right during their career, as it is reported that they sold over 210 million albums worldwide, whilst The Dark Side Of The Moon achieved a total of 1,500 weeks (over 28 years) on the Billboard and Pop Catalogue charts. 3=The Beatles. Jordan, Tuesday, 13 May 2008 17:19 (thirteen years ago) link. Pure Genius .. Fuck those are two boring-ass bands. Despite politely asking the music world to stop harping on about their similarities, Greta Van Fleet are arguably one of the best Led Zeppelin emulators out there. This, by all means, is the most stupid and shallow point of comparison I've seen since the dawn of the internet, Guys you can say that you love pink Floyd Guitar solos more or that you hate led zeppelin I wouldn't mind, But just for the love of God don't ever ever compare any Led Zeppelin member in terms of technicality and instrumental . Reply. On the eve of the release of Led Zeppelin IV, Jimmy Page told Chris Welch, "The words are brilliantthey are the best Robert has ever written.". Who has had a better Solo Careers? Queen AdamL, Jun 30, 2014 #39. jmadtx Black Belt. 11. level 2. Why They Split: . Led Zeppelin 22: Pink Floyd: 11: The Doors 7 Geir Hongro, . Robert Pasbani. Magical Mystery Tour . I'm going with Pink Floyd since Led Zeppelin was more about love and . out of these bands, i listened to a lot of led zep, doors, and pink floyd in high school. III is, indirectly, Led Zeppelin's own version of Pink Floyd's Meddlethe folky, pretty early record that was never too popular and hence a favorite of indie types skeptical of such a massive . LED ZEPPELIN : So , this band is one of the greatest bands of Music History.They redefined Rock and Roll.They redefined culture back in the 70s. Roger Waters had been contributing lyrics to Pink Floyd albums since 1968's A Saucerful of . 20.09.2008. u 18:51 - PINK FLOYD vs LED ZEPPELIN #75 Ginger: Podjednako su dobri.Dobro,Flojdi jesu malo ispred,ali tu su negde.Glasao sam za Zeppelin,imaju manje glasova,chisto da se izjednachi . pink floyd vs. led zeppelin Hola, este es nuestro primer blog y queremos transmitir una posible comparacion entre dos bandas mas que grandes: led zeppelin y pink floyd. Led Zeppelin - Come on guys ,yeah floyd is prog but Zep is much better rock band. I don't like boring songs either, but there are exceptions. Shadow "Classic" Member. Zeppelin have long been regarded by the British Press and otherwise as the best rock band ever, indeed the best band ever. The Classic Rock Forum. Pink Floyd or Led Zeppelin? Led Zeppelin vs. (297) $323.10. Dark Pink - In the halls of Rock's Valhalla sit at the round table, Pink Floyd and Led Zeppelin.Each band has numerous masterpieces of sound, innovation and experience. I've not seen the Led Zeppelin film, but this seemed like too great a match up not to comment on! Pink Floyd (Dark Side, The Wall, Wish You Were Here) 39% (92) Led Zeppelin (Led Zeppelin II, III, & IV) 234 voters have answered this question. Jordan, Tuesday, 13 May 2008 17:19 (thirteen years ago) link. Bieber is sugar cane candy. LED ZEPPELIN VS. . But there's only one of The Mighty Zep! If someone was in the nosebleeds for Led Zeppelin, it wasn't going to be as enjoyable. The 1970's was the best decade for rock music. Led Zeppelin 22: Pink Floyd: 11: The Doors 7 Geir Hongro, . Discussion, debate, and comments on whether Pink Floyd The Wall is better than The Song Remains the Same at Flickchart Sign In Now or Create . 5th UK Tour (2nd part) Date Title Label Venue Source Sound 1973-01-07 Ascension In The Wane Godfather New Theatre, Oxford, England, UK Soundboard 4.5 1973-01-14 Ascension In The Wane Godfather The Empire, Liverpool, England, UK Soundboard 4 1973-01-15 Ascension In The Wane Godfather Trentham Gardens, Stoke, England, UK Soundboard 4.5 1973-01-18 Bradford UK 1973 TDOLZ [] Regardless of how you voted, isn't it sad how music has gone from Zeppelin and Floyd to Bieber and Gaga? The band then found a new drummer, Kenney Jones, ex-Small Faces, the perfect replacement, and . Greta Van Fleet. Another Brick In The Wall Part 3 Immigrant Song Goodbye Cruel World Communication Breakdown Vera . Pink Floyd Led Zeppelin This poll was created on 2008-08-10 15:09:14 by ziggyernie. Zeppelin! The Rolling Stones 5. 2 David Gilmour is a Better Guitarist Than Jimmy Page. They (Lynyrd Skynyrd) don't even come close to Led Zepp's achievements and music style. KAMKA-Z. Your desert island suitcase has room for only one of these dvd's. Which one will you choose? It's just a David Gilmour led Pink Floyd cover band. Vs. Set the controls to the heart of the sun, Let there be more light, Atom Heart mother, Echoes, Money, Any colour you like, Shine, wish you were here, Dogs, Comfortably numb, Run like hell, In the flesh, HIgh hopes. Pink Floyd VS.